75-Year-Old Wisconsin Homeowner Fatally Shoots Man Trying to Force His Way Inside

By Duncan Johnson Editor in Chief •
9mm pistol iStock-1899043258
A 75-year-old Wisconsin homeowner fatally shot a man who reportedly attempted to force his way inside. iStock-1899043258

A 75-year-old Wisconsin homeowner fatally shot a 35-year-old man who allegedly grabbed his glasses and attempted to force his way into his home during an early-morning confrontation. The shooting occurred just minutes after the same man reportedly entered an elderly neighbor’s residence and aggressively pounded and kicked her door after she managed to get him outside.

The incident unfolded around 1:06 a.m. on November 15 in the town of Cassian, Oneida County, Wisconsin. According to the Oneida County Sheriff’s Office account reported by WSAW, the homeowner, identified as 75-year-old Marshall Robinson of Harshaw, armed himself with a handgun after an unknown man began pounding on his residence. When the stranger allegedly attempted to force his way inside, Robinson fired, fatally wounding him.

Intruder Reportedly Entered Elderly Neighbor’s Home First

The deadly confrontation followed another alarming encounter at a neighboring residence. According to a report from the Northwoods Star Journal, an elderly woman contacted Oneida County Dispatch around 1:04 a.m. to report that an unknown man had entered her home. She described the man as intoxicated and told dispatchers that she managed to get him outside before locking her front door.

Rather than immediately leaving the property, the man reportedly began pounding on the woman’s door and aggressively kicking it before eventually departing. Approximately two minutes later, dispatchers received another emergency call from Robinson, who reported that he had shot someone attempting to enter his home. Investigators connected the two encounters, identifying the deceased man as 35-year-old James Roath of Harshaw.

Armed Homeowner Confronts Intruder at Front Door

According to the sheriff’s preliminary investigation, Roath initially pounded on the side of Robinson’s house before locating the front entrance. Robinson retrieved his handgun and opened the door, attempting to determine who was outside his home. The confrontation escalated when Roath reportedly grabbed Robinson’s glasses and attempted to push his way through the doorway, prompting the homeowner to raise his handgun and fire.

Deputies and emergency medical personnel responded to the residence and attempted lifesaving measures, but Roath was pronounced dead at the scene. Authorities have not publicly established whether Roath was armed, how many shots Robinson fired, or whether Roath managed to cross the threshold before being shot. The sheriff’s account does, however, describe an attempted forced entry and physical contact with the homeowner immediately before the shooting.

The encounter illustrates precisely why the Second Amendment’s protection of armed self-defense is so important, particularly for older Americans confronting younger, potentially violent aggressors. Robinson was 75 years old, facing a man four decades younger who, according to investigators, had already entered another elderly resident’s home and behaved aggressively when she locked him outside. While age alone does not establish a person’s physical capabilities, the disparity underscores why the right to keep and bear arms is not reserved for those capable of winning a physical confrontation.

No Arrests Made as District Attorney Reviews Shooting

On November 17, the Oneida County Sheriff’s Office publicly identified both men involved in the fatal encounter. According to Wausau Pilot & Review, investigators reported that no arrests had been made and that their findings would be forwarded to the Oneida County District Attorney’s Office for review. Authorities have not announced a final determination regarding whether Robinson’s use of deadly force was legally justified.

For gun owners, the case is another example of how quickly a dangerous confrontation can unfold at home, even in a quiet rural community. The right to armed self-defense exists because Americans cannot reasonably be expected to depend on physical strength alone or wait for law enforcement to arrive when an immediate threat confronts them. In this case, a 75-year-old homeowner had a handgun available when an unknown man allegedly attempted to force his way into his residence in the middle of the night.

The investigation remains ongoing, and prosecutors will ultimately determine whether any criminal charges are warranted. The incident is among the cases involving armed citizens documented by the AmmoLand Defensive Gun Use Tracker, which follows reports of Americans using firearms to protect themselves and others.

Related: Texas Resident Shoots Shotgun-Armed Home Intruder While on Phone With Police


About Duncan Johnson:

Duncan Johnson is a lifelong firearms enthusiast and unwavering defender of the Second Amendment—where “shall not be infringed” means exactly what it says. A graduate of George Mason University, he enjoys competing in local USPSA and multi-gun competitions whenever he’s not covering the latest in gun rights and firearm policy. Duncan is a regular contributor and editor-in-chief for AmmoLand News and is responsible for AmmoLand’s daily gun-rights reporting and industry coverage.Duncan Johnson