Fifth Circuit Rules Second Amendment Protects Firearm Sales in Major Federal Gun Case

By Duncan Johnson Editor in Chief •
Wall of guns at a gun store. iStock-2261126112
The Fifth Circuit ruled that the Second Amendment’s plain text covers firearm sales in United States v. Deare. iStock-2261126112

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit delivered a significant victory for the Second Amendment on November 19, ruling that the constitutional right to keep and bear arms also protects the sale of firearms. The decision rejects the notion that the federal government can regulate firearm commerce without implicating the constitutional rights of gun owners, buyers, and sellers.

In United States v. Deare, No. 24-30241, a three-judge panel vacated a lower court’s decision denying a constitutional challenge to federal firearms-dealer licensing requirements and sent the case back for further proceedings. Although the ruling does not invalidate federal dealer-licensing laws, it establishes an important constitutional principle: The Second Amendment’s protections extend beyond simply possessing and carrying firearms.

“The plain text of the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms,” the court declared in its published opinion.

Perhaps even more revealing, the federal government conceded during oral arguments that the Second Amendment applies to the commercial sale of firearms. That concession, combined with the court’s holding, undercuts the argument that restrictions on firearm transactions can automatically escape constitutional scrutiny merely because Congress characterizes them as commercial regulations.

Federal Firearms Prosecution Leads to Second Amendment Challenge

The case centers on Jeremiah Micah Deare, who was indicted in the Western District of Louisiana for conspiracy to engage in the business of dealing firearms without a federal firearms license (FFL), in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(1). He also faced charges involving false statements concerning the records of federally licensed firearms dealers.

Deare challenged the constitutionality of the federal licensing requirement and related record-keeping provisions, arguing that they violated the Second Amendment. The district court rejected his challenge, concluding that licensing and record-keeping requirements did not implicate the right to keep and bear arms because they regulated commercial activity rather than firearm possession.

The district court also concluded that the licensing requirements were consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. Deare subsequently went to trial, where a jury convicted him on all counts. He received a sentence of 97 months in federal prison.

On appeal, Deare argued that the lower court had incorrectly excluded firearm sales from the Second Amendment’s protections. The Fifth Circuit agreed that the constitutional analysis could not end simply because the challenged provisions regulated firearm commerce.

Citing its earlier decision in Reese v. ATF, the court explained that the right to possess firearms necessarily includes the ability to acquire them. The appellate judges therefore vacated the district court’s denial of Deare’s motion to dismiss and remanded the case for additional proceedings.

Judge Ho: Constitutional Rights Cannot Be Exercised Without Access to Firearms

Judge James Ho wrote separately to emphasize the fundamental problem with treating firearm sales as activity outside the Second Amendment.

Ho argued that constitutional protections would mean little if the government could prohibit the means by which Americans exercise them. He rejected the distinction between the constitutional rights of firearm owners and the commercial activities necessary for Americans to obtain firearms.

The judge drew a comparison to the First Amendment, noting that constitutional protections for free speech also extend to booksellers and other individuals who distribute protected expression. The government cannot simply eliminate constitutional protection because someone receives compensation for facilitating the exercise of a right.

Ho applied that reasoning to firearm transactions, arguing that the Second Amendment cannot be interpreted to protect firearm possession while leaving those who sell firearms without constitutional protection.

The comparison strikes at a fundamental weakness in arguments seeking to separate firearm commerce from the right to keep and bear arms. Americans cannot meaningfully exercise their right to possess firearms if the government is free to prohibit or unconstitutionally restrict the transactions necessary to acquire them.

Judge Oldham Challenges Federal Licensing Arguments Under Bruen

Judge Andrew Oldham, joined by Judge Ho, issued a separate concurrence explaining why restrictions on firearm sales implicate the constitutional rights of both buyers and sellers.

Oldham argued that the Second Amendment’s protection against infringement extends to government interference with the acquisition and disposition of firearms. A restriction on firearm sales does not merely affect a commercial transaction; it also burdens the constitutional rights of the individual attempting to acquire a firearm.

Under the Supreme Court’s decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, once conduct falls within the Second Amendment’s plain text, the government must justify its restriction by demonstrating consistency with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.

That historical inquiry, rather than an automatic exemption for commercial regulations, is the constitutional question remaining in Deare’s challenge.

Oldham also criticized the Fifth Circuit’s earlier decision in United States v. Peterson, which concerned an unregistered firearm suppressor under the National Firearms Act. He argued that the decision incorrectly treated certain licensing and registration requirements as presumptively constitutional and should not be extended to restrictions on firearm sales.

In Oldham’s view, the government cannot take language concerning carry permits, apply it to firearm registration, and then extend that reasoning yet again to federal restrictions on gun sales. He urged the district court to look instead to the Fifth Circuit’s 2026 decision in Elite Precision Customs LLC v. ATF, which addressed restrictions under Section 922(a).

Although Oldham called for Peterson to be overturned, the Fifth Circuit did not overrule that precedent in Deare. His concurrence nevertheless demonstrates the broader constitutional dispute developing within the federal courts over how licensing and registration requirements should be evaluated under Bruen.

Dissent Would Have Upheld Federal Firearms Regulations

Judge Catharina Haynes dissented, arguing that firearm sellers are not specifically identified in the Second Amendment’s text. She also maintained that Deare had failed to establish that the federal requirements at issue were unconstitutional.

Haynes would have affirmed the district court’s decision rather than returning the case for additional consideration. Her position reflects an interpretation of the Second Amendment that distinguishes between the right to possess firearms and the activities of those who sell them.

That distinction was rejected by the court’s controlling opinion, which expressly recognized that firearm sales fall within the Second Amendment’s plain text.

What the Fifth Circuit Ruling Means for Gun Owners and FFLs

The immediate consequences of United States v. Deare are significant, but the limits of the ruling are equally important.

The Fifth Circuit did not strike down the federal firearms-dealer licensing requirement under Section 922(a)(1), invalidate federal record-keeping obligations, or authorize individuals to engage in the business of dealing firearms without complying with existing federal law.

Instead, the court vacated the lower court’s denial of Deare’s constitutional challenge and returned the case to the Western District of Louisiana. The remaining questions include whether the challenged licensing and record-keeping requirements can survive constitutional scrutiny under the historical-tradition standard established by Bruen.

Because the ruling is a published Fifth Circuit decision, its holding on Second Amendment coverage is binding precedent for federal district courts within the circuit, which includes Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi.

For FFL holders, prospective dealers, and gun owners, the importance of the decision extends beyond Deare’s particular prosecution. Federal licensing restrictions cannot be dismissed as constitutionally irrelevant simply because they regulate the commercial side of the firearms industry. When those restrictions burden conduct covered by the Second Amendment, the government must confront the constitutional questions they raise.

The decision also reinforces an increasingly important principle in Second Amendment litigation: The right to keep and bear arms cannot be meaningfully separated from the ability to acquire them.

The Founders did not write a constitutional amendment protecting the possession of arms while leaving the government unlimited authority to prevent Americans from obtaining those arms in the first place. A right that can be exercised only after navigating whatever restrictions the government chooses to impose is not the uninfringed right guaranteed by the Constitution.

The Fifth Circuit has not yet determined whether the challenged federal dealer-licensing requirements violate that guarantee. But it has made clear that firearm sales are not outside the Second Amendment, and that is an important development for Americans defending their constitutional right to keep and bear arms.

This decision was identified through the AmmoLand 2A NewsRoom. The complete published opinion in United States v. Deare, No. 24-30241, is available from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.

Related: Democrats’ Gun Theft Prevention Act Would Expand ATF Powers, Strip Gun Dealer Protections


About Duncan Johnson:

Duncan Johnson is a lifelong firearms enthusiast and unwavering defender of the Second Amendment—where “shall not be infringed” means exactly what it says. A graduate of George Mason University, he enjoys competing in local USPSA and multi-gun competitions whenever he’s not covering the latest in gun rights and firearm policy. Duncan is a regular contributor and editor-in-chief for AmmoLand News and is responsible for AmmoLand’s daily gun-rights reporting and industry coverage.Duncan Johnson