First Circuit Revives Challenge to Federal Gun Ban Over Old DUIs

By Josh C •
The John Joseph Moakley U.S. Courthouse in Boston, home of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit. (Photo: U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts)

In Massachusetts, a first DUI can cost you your gun rights. Blame the way federal law does the math.

Federal law disarms anyone convicted of a crime punishable by more than a year in prison. There's an exception for state misdemeanors punishable by two years or less, and Massachusetts does call a first or second DUI a misdemeanor. But the maximum sentence is two and a half years. That extra six months puts it on the wrong side of the line.


Thomas Marshall found that out the hard way. His DUIs date to 1997 and 2005. When he moved to New Hampshire in 2023 and tried to buy a gun, the background check stopped the sale. On Nov. 13, the First Circuit partly revived his challenge to the ban in Marshall v. Blanche.

Don't read too much into it yet. The win is procedural. The court didn't decide whether the ban is constitutional as applied to Marshall, and he's still prohibited.


A pre-Bruen precedent loses its grip


In June 2024, Marshall sued the federal government in New Hampshire to block enforcement of the felon-in-possession ban, 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1), and the background check rules built on it. He said he wants a handgun and a long gun for home defense. U.S. District Judge Paul Barbadoro dismissed the case in June 2025, relying on United States v. Torres-Rosario, a 2011 First Circuit decision that all but shut the door on as-applied challenges to the ban.

The problem is that Torres-Rosario predates the Supreme Court's 2022 Bruen decision, which requires the government to show a gun law fits the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. In September, the First Circuit applied that test in United States v. Levasseur, a Maine man's as-applied challenge to his own § 922(g)(1) conviction. Levasseur lost, but the Marshall panel said that after that decision, Torres-Rosario no longer controls.

That matters beyond this case. Trial courts in Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island and Puerto Rico can no longer toss challenges like Marshall's on that old precedent alone. They have to do the history work.


Tripped up by interstate commerce


Here's the odd part. The possession ban only reaches guns that have moved in interstate or foreign commerce, and Marshall's complaint never said he plans to own one that has. The court pointed out that New Hampshire had at least 30 licensed gun manufacturing facilities in 2023, so a gun bought there might never have crossed a state line.

Because of that, the court found he lacks standing to challenge the possession ban as written. It's a strange place for a Second Amendment case to snag.

His challenge to the background check denial is a different story. That goes back to the trial court for Bruen's history test. The panel left it to the trial judge whether that denied purchase also gives him standing to go after the possession ban, though it said that's "not at all clear."


The restoration wildcard


DOJ now has a rights restoration rule that lets prohibited persons apply to get their federal gun rights back (TFB covered the rollout). The court said that makes sending the case back "particularly appropriate."

The two sides disagree over whether the restoration process alone sinks his challenge, and the trial court will have to sort that out too. Marshall hasn't ruled out applying, and decades-old DUIs aren't among the offenses that trigger the rule's presumptive denials. He may end up getting his gun through DOJ before he ever gets a ruling.