First Circuit Revives Second Amendment Challenge Over Two Old DUI Convictions

Two drunk-driving convictions from 1997 and 2005 have kept a New Hampshire man from legally buying a firearm. Now, a federal appeals court says the precedent used to dismiss his Second Amendment challenge no longer controls.
On November 13, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit vacated the dismissal of Thomas Marshall’s lawsuit, ordering a federal judge to reconsider his challenge under the Supreme Court’s Bruen framework. That means the federal government’s use of Marshall’s decades-old DUI convictions to deny his firearm purchase must face a constitutional analysis rooted in the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation, rather than the circuit’s old precedent.
The ruling does not restore Marshall’s gun rights or strike down the federal prohibition. But it removes a major legal obstacle that previously prevented his challenge from receiving that historical analysis.
Two Old DUI Convictions Trigger a Federal Gun Ban
According to Marshall’s complaint, he was convicted of driving under the influence in Massachusetts in 1997 and again in 2005. After moving to New Hampshire in 2023, he attempted to purchase a firearm but received a denial through the state’s background-check process based on those convictions.
The problem stems from 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1), which generally prohibits anyone convicted of a crime punishable by more than one year in prison from possessing firearms or ammunition.
Federal law contains an exception for certain state misdemeanors punishable by two years or less. However, Marshall’s Massachusetts DUI offenses carried a potential sentence of up to two and a half years, placing them outside that exception and making him a prohibited person under federal law.
That distinction matters. A conviction does not necessarily have to be classified as a felony under state law to trigger a federal firearms prohibition. The maximum punishment authorized for an offense can be enough to deprive someone of the ability to lawfully purchase or possess a gun, regardless of the sentence actually imposed.
Marshall’s complaint states that he wants to purchase a handgun and a long gun to protect himself and his family inside his home. Instead, his convictions from more than two decades ago continue to stand between him and the exercise of his Second Amendment rights.
First Circuit Says Pre-Bruen Precedent No Longer Controls
Marshall filed his lawsuit in June 2024, challenging the constitutionality of applying the federal gun prohibition to him. In June 2025, U.S. District Judge Paul Barbadoro dismissed the case, relying heavily on the First Circuit’s 2011 decision in United States v. Torres-Rosario.
That older ruling had largely foreclosed individualized Second Amendment challenges to § 922(g)(1), except in unusually narrow circumstances. The district court concluded that Marshall’s repeated DUI convictions did not qualify for that limited exception, characterizing his conduct as a serious threat to public safety. But the constitutional landscape has changed since 2011.
In New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022), the Supreme Court rejected the use of interest-balancing tests to determine whether firearm restrictions violate the Second Amendment. Courts must instead examine the amendment’s text and, when that text protects the conduct at issue, determine whether the government can establish a relevant historical tradition supporting its restriction.
Writing for the unanimous three-judge panel, Chief Judge David Barron explained that the First Circuit’s September 2026 decision in United States v. Levasseur clarified that this historical framework applies to challenges against § 922(g)(1).
Addressing the older precedent, Barron wrote:
“But at least in light of our decision in Levasseur, we no longer think that Torres-Rosario controls.”
Because the district court never conducted the required historical analysis, the appeals court ordered the case returned for further proceedings.
That is the central development for Second Amendment advocates. The government cannot rely on Torres-Rosario alone to defeat Marshall’s challenge. The lower court must now examine whether the restrictions being applied to him can survive the constitutional analysis required by Bruen and further explained in United States v. Rahimi.
Appeals Court Draws a Distinction Between Gun Purchases and Possession
The decision also addressed an important procedural limitation involving Marshall’s standing to challenge the federal prohibition.
The First Circuit determined that Marshall had not adequately established standing to bring a pre-enforcement challenge to criminal prosecution for possessing a firearm. Under § 922(g)(1), the possession offense includes an interstate-commerce requirement, and Marshall had not alleged that the firearm he intended to possess met that requirement.
However, the court allowed his challenge involving the denial of his firearm purchase to proceed.
Marshall had already been denied a firearm through the background-check process, and the federal government did not dispute the lower court’s determination that he had standing to challenge the restrictions responsible for that denial.
The appellate judges also recognized that restrictions on commercial firearm purchases could raise different historical questions from criminal prohibitions on firearm possession. They left those questions for the district court rather than deciding them on appeal.
This distinction means Marshall has not obtained a ruling permitting him to possess firearms. His challenge to the government’s use of his prohibited-person status to block a firearm purchase is what moves forward.
DOJ’s New Gun Rights Restoration Process Enters the Fight
The First Circuit also instructed the district court to consider a significant change in federal policy: the Justice Department’s new process for restoring firearms rights under 18 U.S.C. § 925(c).
The DOJ established new regulations under 28 C.F.R. Part 107 in August 2026, allowing individuals subject to federal firearms disabilities to apply to the Attorney General for relief.
The regulations establish a process for reviewing applications, including consideration of an applicant’s prior offenses, subsequent conduct, and potential danger to public safety.
According to the appellate opinion, DOJ informed the court in February 2026 that the Attorney General had granted relief from federal firearms disabilities to 22 individuals. That figure reflects the government’s representation at the time, not necessarily the current number of approvals.
The parties disagree over whether the existence of this restoration process affects Marshall’s constitutional challenge, including whether it provides an alternative remedy or changes the Second Amendment analysis.
The First Circuit declined to resolve those questions, leaving them for the district court.
For gun owners, the distinction between a constitutional right and a discretionary restoration process remains important. The Second Amendment protects an individual right to keep and bear arms, while § 925(c) allows the government to decide whether certain prohibited individuals should receive relief from federal restrictions.
Whether the availability of that administrative process can justify continued enforcement of the prohibition against Marshall remains an open question.
What Happens Next for Marshall and Other Gun Owners?
The case now returns to the U.S. District Court for the District of New Hampshire, where the government will have to defend the challenged restrictions under the applicable Bruen historical analysis.
The First Circuit did not strike down § 922(g)(1), restore Marshall’s firearm rights, or decide whether his two DUI convictions constitutionally justify the federal prohibition. Those issues remain unresolved.
Nevertheless, the ruling opens the door to renewed constitutional scrutiny of federal firearms disabilities within the First Circuit, which covers Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, and Puerto Rico.
For Americans who remain prohibited from owning firearms because of decades-old convictions, Marshall v. Blanche raises a fundamental question: Can the government permanently deny someone the right to armed self-defense based on past conduct without demonstrating that such a restriction is consistent with the Constitution’s text and the nation’s historical tradition?
Marshall has not won that argument yet. But the federal government can no longer rely on the same pre-Bruen precedent to avoid confronting it in his case.
This developing Second Amendment court case was identified through AmmoLand 2A NewsRoom. The ruling is available in the First Circuit’s November 13, 2026, opinion.
About Duncan Johnson:
Duncan Johnson is a lifelong firearms enthusiast and unwavering defender of the Second Amendment—where “shall not be infringed” means exactly what it says. A graduate of George Mason University, he enjoys competing in local USPSA and multi-gun competitions whenever he’s not covering the latest in gun rights and firearm policy. Duncan is a regular contributor and editor-in-chief for AmmoLand News and is responsible for AmmoLand’s daily gun-rights reporting and industry coverage.