Investigators: Evidence Supports Self-Defense After 42-Year-Old Threatens to Kill Girlfriend’s Son During Northport Apartment Fight

By Luke McCoy •

Key Takeaways

  • A 42-year-old man died after being stabbed inside Valley Hills Apartments in Northport, Alabama on Friday night.
  • Investigators say the man was assaulting his girlfriend and threatened to kill her 19-year-old son during the fight.
  • The son stepped in when the assault resumed, and the suspect was stabbed and died from his injuries.
  • Both the woman and her son were injured during the confrontation.
  • The Tuscaloosa County Violent Crimes Unit says evidence supports self-defense, but the case will go to a grand jury.

Estimated reading time: 2 minutes

NORTHPORT, AL — A 42-year-old man died after being stabbed inside a Northport apartment Friday night. Investigators say he had been assaulting his girlfriend and threatened to kill her 19-year-old son during the fight. Investigators say the evidence supports the claims of self-defense, and the case is headed to the Tuscaloosa County Grand Jury.

As reported by WBRC, the Tuscaloosa County Violent Crimes Unit said Northport Police were called to the Valley Hills Apartments for a reported stabbing. Officers found the man dead inside the apartment, and VCU investigators were called to the scene to handle the investigation.

Investigators spoke with a woman they describe as a witness. She told them she had just gotten back to the apartment after delivering food for work when an argument started between her and her 42-year-old boyfriend, who also lived there.

Then it turned physical. The boyfriend began assaulting her. Her 19-year-old son stepped in and stopped it.

It did not stay stopped. The son left the room. The fight started again. He went back.

During that fight, police said, the 42-year-old threatened to kill the son. He was stabbed. He died from his injuries.

Investigators said both the woman and her son were injured in the confrontation.

Some people will fix on the fact that the son left the room and then came back. The sequence investigators describe matters here. He went back because the assault on his mother had started again. Walking back toward someone who is being hurt is not the same thing as picking a fight.

Deadly force is justified only against an imminent threat of death or serious bodily harm. In my read, a renewed assault on a woman who had already been attacked once was a threat on its own. A grown man telling the 19-year-old he would kill him took away whatever ambiguity was left.

More from USA Carry:

There was no gun in this one. A lot of my readers think about self-defense in terms of firearms and Alabama concealed carry laws, but the question a grand jury asks is the same no matter what was in someone’s hand. The mindset is the same too. Know when the line has been crossed, and know that you may have to answer for every step you took after it.

Investigators have not released the names of anyone involved. Even with the evidence and testimony pointing to self-defense, according to officials, the case will be presented to the Tuscaloosa County Grand Jury, and the grand jury makes that call.

Read the original story: Investigators: Evidence Supports Self-Defense After 42-Year-Old Threatens to Kill Girlfriend’s Son During Northport Apartment Fight