Permit Before You Buy: Third Circuit Panel Questions Gun Rights Bid to Block Delaware’s Handgun Permit Law

By Luke McCoy •

Key Takeaways

  • A Third Circuit panel questioned gun rights advocates' bid to block Delaware's law requiring a permit before buying a handgun.
  • Advocates want the Third Circuit to decide whether Second Amendment protections apply to acquiring a firearm at all.
  • Federal appeals courts have reached different answers on that threshold question, and the U.S. Supreme Court declined the issue in October.
  • Under the Supreme Court's 2022 Bruen decision, if buying a gun is covered by the Second Amendment, Delaware must justify its law historically.
  • Delaware's handgun permit-to-purchase law remains in effect while the Third Circuit considers the challenge.

Estimated reading time: 2 minutes

DOVER, DE — A panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit on Wednesday, Nov. 18, questioned gun rights advocates’ bid to block Delaware’s law requiring individuals to obtain a permit before buying a handgun.

Last year I covered Delaware’s Controversial Permit-to-Purchase Law Set to Take Effect November 16, when the law was weeks from enforcement and already facing a court challenge. That fight has now reached the federal appeals court whose decisions bind Delaware, as reported by Bloomberg Law.

According to Bloomberg Law, the advocates see the case as a chance for the Third Circuit to answer a threshold question. Do rules on acquiring a firearm, meaning how you buy one in the first place, fall within the scope of the Second Amendment at all? That question has split federal appeals courts. Different circuits have reached different answers, so the same kind of law can face different treatment depending on where you live. The U.S. Supreme Court declined to take up the issue in October.

That threshold question carries most of the weight. Under the Supreme Court’s 2022 Bruen decision, when the Second Amendment’s text covers the conduct, the state has to justify its law by pointing to the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. If buying a gun counts as part of keeping and bearing one, Delaware carries that burden. If a court decides acquisition sits outside the Amendment’s text, the law never has to clear that historical test. A right to keep and bear arms that does not reach the purchase leaves the government a lot of room to regulate the front door.

A panel is a smaller group of the court’s judges assigned to hear a case, and this one has not ruled. No opinion or hearing record was available for this story, and the account of Wednesday’s argument rests on Bloomberg Law’s reporting. Tough questions at oral argument do not always predict how a court will decide.

More from USA Carry:

Nothing about Wednesday’s argument blocks the law. Anyone in Delaware looking to buy a handgun still has to get the permit first. A sound carry mindset includes knowing Delaware’s gun laws and permit rules before you walk into a gun shop, not after.

I will continue tracking the challenge to Delaware’s handgun permit-to-purchase law as the Third Circuit weighs it.

Read the original story: Permit Before You Buy: Third Circuit Panel Questions Gun Rights Bid to Block Delaware’s Handgun Permit Law