Supreme Court Won’t Touch Maryland’s Sprawling ‘Sensitive Place’ Carry Bans, But Thomas Signals the Fight Isn’t Over
Key Takeaways
- The U.S. Supreme Court on November 16, 2026, declined to hear Novotny v. Moore, leaving Maryland's location-based carry bans in place.
- Maryland law bans carrying firearms at public demonstrations, on mass transit, at healthcare facilities, and at locations selling alcohol for on-site consumption.
- Justice Clarence Thomas wrote a statement saying he is skeptical these laws are consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation.
- Thomas warned that expanding the sensitive-place category to all places of public congregation would eviscerate the general right to publicly carry arms for self-defense.
- Thomas indicated the Court should take up the sensitive-place question in a future, more narrowly focused case.
Estimated reading time: 4 minutes
WASHINGTON, DC — The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday, November 16, 2026, declined to hear Novotny v. Moore, the challenge to Maryland’s web of location-based carry bans, leaving in place a Fourth Circuit ruling that upheld nearly all of them. The order was a one-line denial of certiorari, which means the Justices simply refused to take the case. No reasoning, no ruling on the merits. For now, Maryland’s bans stand.
In September I covered the challengers’ final filing in their last brief before the Court decided whether to step in. The Court has now decided, and it stepped back. But the denial did not come quietly. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote a statement respecting the denial that reads like a warning shot, and that statement is the real news here.
Here is what Maryland law does, in Thomas’s own summary. A person may not carry a firearm at public demonstrations, on mass transit, at places of amusement, at healthcare facilities, at locations that sell alcohol for on-site consumption, and across tens of thousands of acres of state park and forest land. Those bans sit on top of longstanding restrictions and a 2023 batch of new ones Governor Wes Moore signed after the Supreme Court’s 2022 Bruen decision recognized a right to carry in public for self-defense.
The challengers, who include individual Maryland residents and the Maryland affiliate of the National Rifle Association, argued the state stretched the idea of a “sensitive place” far past anything history supports. A federal district court split the difference, blocking the bans on public demonstrations and on places that sell alcohol for on-site consumption while upholding the rest, and the Fourth Circuit then upheld all of the challenged restrictions, as reported by CBS News. The Fourth Circuit’s opinion is captioned Kipke v. Moore, and it is the decision the Court just left standing.
Thomas agreed with the decision not to grant review, but only on narrow procedural grounds. His problem was with the shape of the case, not its substance. Because the petitioners challenged so many different statutes at once, each resting on a different slice of history, Thomas wrote that “the breadth of petitioners’ challenge would complicate our review.” In an appropriate and more narrowly focused case, he said, the Court “should consider the scope of States’ authority to ban firearms in ‘sensitive places.'”
Read that as an invitation. Thomas said plainly that he is “skeptical” these laws are consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation, the test Bruen set. He walked through what that history actually shows: early American legislatures sometimes barred weapons in legislative assemblies, polling places, and courthouses, and that was about it. As he put it, “the historical record yields relatively few 18th- and 19th-century ‘sensitive places’ where weapons were altogether prohibited.”
What matters to anyone who carries is the line he drew next. Thomas warned that expanding the sensitive-place category “to all places of public congregation” would “eviscerate the general right to publicly carry arms for self-defense.” Then he named names. New Jersey bans guns in at least 25 places including zoos, libraries, casinos, and state-owned beaches. New York has designated 20, from any place of worship to certain health-licensed residential settings. California lists 29, including athletic facilities, financial institutions, and any permitted public gathering. The courts of appeals, he wrote, “have largely blessed these ahistorical ventures.”
That is the whole fight in one paragraph. The sensitive-place label was meant for a handful of buildings the government actively secures with guards and metal detectors. States have pasted it onto the ordinary places people live their lives, the parks, the restaurants, the transit they use every day, exactly the places where you alone are responsible for your own safety. A serious carry mindset means knowing where your permit stops meaning anything, and in Maryland the list of places it stops meaning anything keeps growing.
Maryland also does not recognize out-of-state permits, which means these location bans compound an already closed door for nonresidents. If you travel and want to know which states honor your permit and which do not, my concealed carry permit reciprocity maps lay it out state by state.
More from USA Carry:
- Maryland Stretched ‘Sensitive Place’ Across Public Life. Now SAF, FPC and Maryland Shall Issue Have Filed Their Last Brief Before the Court Decides Whether to Step In. – USA Carry
- FPC Just Asked the Supreme Court to End Maryland’s Carry Bans, and the List of Banned Places Is Staggering
- Split Decision in Gun Rights Case: Maryland Law Upheld in Most Places, Rejected on Private Property Carry
- Woman With VA Concealed Carry Permit Arrested After Self-Defense in Maryland — SAF Urges Supreme Court Review
- Valid D.C. Permit, Two Maryland Convictions Anyway: Eight 2A Groups Urging Maryland’s Highest Court to Hear Duvall Carry Case
A cert denial sets no precedent and decides nothing on the merits. The Fourth Circuit’s ruling binds Maryland and the rest of that circuit, and the sensitive-place question remains open everywhere else. Thomas made clear the Court is looking for the right vehicle, one law, one clean historical question, instead of ten at once. When that case arrives, the analysis he laid out Monday is the roadmap.
I will continue tracking the sensitive-place litigation as narrower challenges work their way toward the Court.
Read the original story: Supreme Court Won’t Touch Maryland’s Sprawling ‘Sensitive Place’ Carry Bans, But Thomas Signals the Fight Isn’t Over